Unclaimed
50 reviews

Rafter's Tavern

claimClaim
marker Callicoon, New York

Reviews

50 reviews
R P

06/24/2020
We went recently and have to say not impressed by food or service. (Note this is during COVID-19 take out only service)We called and ordered several dishes. The wings ( Honey BBQ) a lot of BBQ no real honey sweetness to it. Garden Salad the salad was not very fresh more like several days - week old greens. Vegetable Burrito same deal not very fresh greens. A Specialty Burger and the Bun was not fresh, burger tasted as if par boiled a few days ago, frozen and then finished on the grill. Over all very disappointing to try this place after seeing all the great reviews but some people dont know great or even good. I was born and raised in NYC - Long Island Area and we know the difference between great food and poor food. This at best was two stars. Also waiting 15-20 minutes while a few drinks were made for someone and our packaged and bagged food sat by the service window!!! So all the food was Luke warm at best not warm ( we went by car down by the Delaware to eat, only 2 minutes away. The view was great, food not so much) I know you will say hard to get really fresh vegetables but I also own a home up nearby there in PA and fresh produce, dairy and meat are easily found. I have a hard time saying if I will try again after such a substandard first try. Sorry but This one I can not recommend
Roger Heim

06/24/2020
Probably one of the best burgers I've ever had. Try the Rafters Burger with the poblano peppers
Mary Dougherty

06/23/2020
The food was delicious and the waiter entertaining
Larry Wagner

06/18/2020
Great burgers and a really nice bar. They have live music frequently and did a great job renovating this old place.
William John Ross

06/17/2020
Great decor, great food and great service.